By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Torillian said:
sales2099 said:

Why did you group them together? Xbox trolls are not the main cause, though I will not deny their contributions. There’s just as many if not more positive reviews from people who liked it. 

You aren’t even open to the possibility that the majority are people who liked LOU1? People are allowed to feel divided on the direction of the story and characters, on top of who you play as. The ending is not universally praised either (where as review copies werent the whole game people based their review on).  

Wait wait, are you claiming that the review copies just didn't have the back half of the game? My understanding was that they weren't allowed to discuss the back half in their review but they were still allowed to play that part of the game. 

Btw, not that weird of a request. Even as an amateur video game reviewer we got some review copies that came with the stipulation we not discuss story details beyond a certain point. Would have to look through my review list to try and remember which game specifically. 

No that’s what I meant. That their score could only be based on the first half right? That was my understanding. It’s not a weird request, but it’s the second half moments of the game that are largely responsible for the divisive aspects. 



Xbox: Best hardware, Game Pass best value, best BC, more 1st party genres and multiplayer titles.