I want games to look and feel like block buster movies at theaters, and not like soap operas. When my TV is set to higher fps things I watch look weird and overly fluid, taking away from the epicness of it all. Graphics over frame rate for all the RPGs, frame rate for sports games.
You should do some reading on the soap opera effect. Your understanding of it seems a little off. Its not a factor for video games, unless your TV is doing something really weird.