Should Halo Infinite drop Xbox One and go Scarlet exclusive?

[Mr Puggsly]

curl-6 said:

Mr Puggsly said:

Not great comparisons.

Far Cry 4 is an open world game, much more ambitious than games like Killzone:SF or Ryse. Yet it still had visuals fairly par with those 8th gen exclusives and more impressive in other ways.

When making comparison you should always consider 30 fps vs 60 fps. Advanced Warfare is a 60 fps game and visually is built around that.

Battlefield 4 on X1 and PS4 look arguably better than both Killzone:SF and Ryse. But since its a 60 fps game, it had to pull back on polish.

Honestly, I wouldn't say any crossgen games at all were in Ryse or Shadowfall's league.

Well I played all the games mentioned. You can give the edge to games like Killzone:SF and Ryse, but they're linear games aiming for 30 fps.

Its also worth noting the most ambitious game mentioned is Far Cry 4. Its a dynamic open world with tons of AIs running around, but it worked fine on 7th gen specs. Yet people seem to have impression we need 9th gen consoles to create experiences like that. I'm not sure why people think X1 is holding back a Halo game. What do they expect 9th gen specs to do for the series?