Do you think Google Stadia is doomed to fail?

[potato_hamster]

RolStoppable said:

potato_hamster said:

Ahh, so Switch gets lumped into the PS4 and XBox One generation when its convenient for you. Got it. What was that about twisting? Steam isn't limited by generations, it's automatically next gen. It's obvious you made an assumption, and now you're projecting your attempts to save face on me. You keep forgetting that I don't care about my reputation here! I have no reason to try and save face when I'm wrong. But you do...

I didn't barge into this thread to have a go at you. That's just more paranoia from you. You keep acting that if you can come up with a reason why my argument could possibly be made against any poster before you that I'm targeting you as if you get to decide where arguments are appropriate and where they're not. I cannot keep stating this for you: Your opinions are not fact despite your attempts to treat them as such. And now you're backseat moderating me. What was that about standards that are appropriate for this website?

And again, nice dodge on the "straw man argument" definition you keep messing up.

I'll show you the post in question for the third time now:

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=9029008

JRPGfan said:

It being free at 1080p does change things somewhat.
But then again next gen consoles will all be 4k.

Does a statement refering to next gen consoles include Steam? No, definitely not, because Steam is not a console.

Is it possible that the statement includes Switch? No, because it mentions 4k resolution which Switch does not support.

Additionally, if the logical deductions of the presented quote are still insufficient for whatever reason, JRPGfan counts Switch towards the same generation as the PS4 and XB1, therefore he does not include Switch when he is talking about next gen consoles. You are free to ask him about that, if you don't believe me.

So none of this here is twisting on my part and it's all verifiable.

So you believe in that one statement he's saying he believes that the only competition to the Google Stadia will be "next gen consoles" and not the expression of a thought that contributes to his overall thought process about some of (and not only) the competitors Google Stadia will have. JRPGfan himself later clarifies exactly what he feels Stadia's competition is, but you continue to discard this because you wish to twist this one sentence to mean more than it actually says.

This is about as clear cut example of "cherry picking" as it gets. But please, go on.