Do you think Google Stadia is doomed to fail?

[potato_hamster]

RolStoppable said:

potato_hamster said:

Let's just take a moment to marvel at how confident you are in your apparently poor reading comprehension. Did he or did he not list two other platforms that already exist that he feels Stadia is a competitor of, that you conveniently ignored in your "confirmation" that you did not do a pricing comparison to that were much more valid comparisons to make just like I was saying all along? Damn. This is like a flat earther doing an experiment that clearly points to the earth being a globe but because he doesn't have the knowledge or experience to interpret the results correctly, thinks it's actually evidence the earth is flat.

Also, nice dodge on your misunderstanding of "straw man argument".

I don't see how the additions of Switch and Steam negate JRPGfan's much earlier post about next gen consoles which refers to only the PS5 and Scarlett.

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=9029008

Your point has been that it was wrong of me to assume that JRPGfan draws a comparison between Stadia, PS5 and Scarlet, but nothing he has said has contradicted this.

I know what a straw man is and it's not wrong of me to think that you have bad intentions in this thread based on the way you have argued about what the comparison of this thread is about. You continue to twist and spin to make me look bad, the latest example being the post I just quoted.

Silly Rol, I don't have to twist or spin your words to make you look bad. They do that all on their own!

And again, my argument since the beginning is that trying to determine that the cost of ownership of the Stadia vs the PS5/Xbox Scarlet is ridiculous because we know nothing about those platforms. You argued that it was the only valid comparison to make because those were the consoles the OP was referring to as competition to Stadia. The OP then explicitly lists which consoles he feels its competing against, which include PS5/XBox Scarlett, as well as two other platforms, which are existing platforms with known costs associated with them that clearly would be much more valid comparisons to make, and you think confirms that your price comparison between the PS5/Xbox Scarlett was valid all along as a result when if you made a cost comparison between Stadia and Switch in the first place, we wouldn't be having this conversation, would we?


Whether or not an argument is a "Straw man" or no has literally nothing to do with the intentions of the argument or the paranoia of the person claiming the argument is a straw man, so you've again demonstrated that you don't know what a straw man argument is. Besides, one can easily argue that your comparison between PS5/Xbox Scarlett and Stadia is a prime example of "bad intentions" that you have shown in this thread. Looks to me like you're just projecting your own thoughts and feelings onto those that are pointing out the flaws in your argument.