By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
JWeinCom on 17 November 2018
Edit Thread
Lonely_Dolphin said:
JWeinCom said:

No... it really can't be said about every game.  Because fans of other franchises may be making valid criticisms.  The criticisms I've seen from hardcore fans (simplified battle system, no random encounters, and so on.)  Do not seem to be.

I don't know why you'd think my initial post implies the game has no faults.  I said I thought a score of 81 was fair.  If I thought the game had no faults, I would be arguing that an 81 is unfair and it should get 100.  Wouldn't I?

Yes it can as every game has criticisms and fans. Whether you think the criticisms are valid or not is only your opinion, just like whoever making the statement would have the opinion that they're not valid, so the statement is always able to be made even if it is an unreasonable one.

So you believe the reasons the game got points docked are completely different from fan criticisms. I've not looked at reviews admittedly but I have to doubt that. Now you've provided a mere two reasons that you say are invalid without any explanation. I'm not gonna agree with you of course, but I would like to see where you're coming from, try to understand the other side and all that.

Yes, if we want to be really technical about it, anyone can make any claim they wish.  Obviously I meant that it could not be made accurately.