By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Lonely_Dolphin said:
JWeinCom said:

Nope.  Sorry.  I referred to a specific group of complaints by a specific group of people.  I did not make some kind of sweeping statement about every criticism of this game and every other.   This is basic logic.

It is possible to have valid reasons to dislike a game.  Most of the reasons I've seen for this game, particularly from hardcore fans, are not.

That doesn't change the fact that the same statement can be said for every game ever, all you have to do is replace the word Pokemon in your sentence with any other game. To actually be specific, you'd need to name people's reasons and explain why they're invalid. For example: "Splatoon having gyro aiming is not a flaw when it's completely optional." Here you can't replace Splatoon with any other game as the sentence would no longer make sense, that's how you know you're being specific.

With that said, what are these reasons you've seen? You said most reasons, so you do believe the game has legit faults afterall then despite your initial post, that's good! No game is without flaw afterall.

No... it really can't be said about every game.  Because fans of other franchises may be making valid criticisms.  The criticisms I've seen from hardcore fans (simplified battle system, no random encounters, and so on.)  Do not seem to be.

I don't know why you'd think my initial post implies the game has no faults.  I said I thought a score of 81 was fair.  If I thought the game had no faults, I would be arguing that an 81 is unfair and it should get 100.  Wouldn't I?