scottie on 20 June 2008
The original post sounds like a glowing review
Positive
"a genuinely thrilling storyline" also "the mysterious storyline"
"Item combination is one of the game's strengths and independent control of your two arms (is good)"
"the amazing atmosphere"
"the satisfaction when you figure out the puzzles"
"the fantastic implementation of the Wii controls"
Negative
"Not being able to pick up an item that has a huge 'A' button prompt until you've turned around and looked at it from a different angle."
"the vehicle controls are awful"
Conclusion
"Alone In The Dark is an utter disappointment."
Wow, that's not the conclusion I would have made
