Would you save Ellie?

[CrazyGamer2017]

Ultr said:

CrazyGamer2017 said:

Oh crap, I'm not saving children RIGHT NOW, so I guess I'm wrong: Rape and murder Ellie in Joel's situation cause since I'm not saving kids RIGHT NOW my argument has no legs to stand on...

You guys get through very crazy types of reasoning to justify something that is obviously evil and I am baffled by that.

And you're not even the worst. At least if she's your daughter you'd try to save her if something like what happens in that game happened to you. But you don't want to say that you'd save her if she was not your kid and that says it all dude.

You are as hypocritical as it gets. You are even stating that you are inactive. One time you will realise that your inaction also kills.

If my daughter would die of hunger in africa I would immediately fly out and save her.
Right now somebody elses daughter is dying of hunger in africa. Am I flying out no? so whats your point?
Where is your moral compas right now?
I dont think you understand what you are talking about.

I'm honest I say things as they are. Neither YOU NOR ME are flying to Africa to save kids so we are equal on this.

Our difference is NOT in flying far off to save someone but saving a child that is RIGHT IN FRONT OF US. I would not SELL ELLIE to the Fireflies EVEN if she's not my daughter. You'd SELL her BECAUSE she is not your daughter. That is a huge difference and the horrible thing here is that you don't seem to realize it, you don' see it, you try to justify that by putting the "we don't fly to Africa to save kids" argument. It's an interesting one and we can discuss it in a thread that goes with THAT topic but the fact you try to use that argument to justify selling out a kid only because that kid is NOT your daughter shows how broken your moral compass is.

And AGAIN you're not even the worst: At least if she's your daughter you'd try to save her.