OoT or MGS4?

[TheRealMafoo]

tabsina said:

TheRealMafoo said:

tabsina said:
Well, imho.. given that the comment "MGS4 is the best game this generation" would be a wildly debated one, it's hard to then go one step further to say "is it also the best of the best games of each generation?"

 

I would debate if OoT was the best game for it's generation as well. I would put Fallout and System Shock 2 above it.

 

If you want to say best game of all time relative to it's it's generation, It's neither. That goes to either Pac-man, or Tetras.

whisper: smb3

:P

 

No, not that one. For a game to be "best of all time relative to it's generation", it had to have a huge impact on gaming. I did forget one however that was more impact-full then the two above:

Super Mario Brothers (the first one)

While Pac-Man would be a close second (that really hit main stream culture like no other game), SMB did restart this whole home console thing, so it takes the cake.