Detroit: Become Human Reviews: 79 Metacritic, 80 OpenCritic

[fauzman]

freebs2 said:

fauzman said:

Logically when most of the scores are 80-90 and a few score 40 or so then yes it is a possibility.

Referring also to my reply to CGI, if the actual arguments of the review are poor or don't reflect the score than yes. In any other case every reviewer should be given the benefit of the doubt and any opinion should be treated as equal.

Whenever i look at the scores for a game i do usually look at a subsection including the highest rating and lowest rating scores. And yes there will likely be considerable variation in games. However some of the extremely low scores for this game seem way too silly.

 

I have read some of the reviews. Yes i take their point  about the issues they had with the game. However i  agree with CGI in that a game with average scores  of 8 shouldn't be getting a score like 4, especially when their scores refer to narrative and control issues. 

They are entitled to their opinion of course but i dont like it and don't think it is fair reflection of the game (based on other reviews of course). 

Last edited by fauzman - on 25 May 2018