Gen 1 had the worst Pokémon, in my opinion

[HyrulianScrolls]

LuccaCardoso1 said:

Kaneman! said:
I don't know man, the following are all worse for me:
- the garbage pokemon
- the ice cream
- the sword
- the keys
- the heart fish

I'm sure I forgot some.

I don't see why a garbage pokémon would be any worse than a sludge pokémon. I don't see why an ice cream pokémon would be any worse than an egg pokémon. I don't see why a possessed sword would be any worse than a living pokéball (not even a possessed pokéball, just a pokéball that somehow lives). I don't see why a keychain pokémon would be any worse than a magnet pokémon. I don't see why a heart fish pokémon would be any worse than a regular crab.

For the record, what the Pokemon is isn't so much the issue as the execution. Aegislash may be a possessed sword which sounds silly, but the execution of the design is incredible:

 

Compare to this atrocity on the other hand: