Games That are Good at One Genre but Suck at Another

[VAMatt]

VGPolyglot said:
My life is a great survival horror game, but a horrible dating sim.

Have you bothered to build in dating sim elements?  Does your character have dating apps on his cell phone, and use them during cut scenes? Has he decided that dating is important to him, and he'll kill any m-fer that gets in his way as he tries to find true love?