By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
JRPGfan said:
Jumpin said:

I don’t think 3DS is even close to the Wii, to be honest. Some of the games on Wii included:

 

  • Super Mario Galaxy  (I give you this one)
  • Wii Sports
  • Legend of Zelda  (3ds has plenty of)
  • Super Paper Mario  (this was a horrible paper mario game)
  • Metroid Prime
  • Fire Emblem (3ds has plenty of, and better version that the wii had)
  • WarioWare  (really?)
  • Forever Blue/Endless Ocean
  • Resident Evil 4  (3ds has plenty of)
  • Resident Evil Umbrella Chronicles (3ds has plenty of)
  • Call of Duty 3 and 4 
  • Medal of Honour
  • Okami
  • Fifa  (sports games, who cares really?)
  • PES  (sports games, who cares really?)
  • Tiger Woods PGA (sports games, who cares really?)
  • Madden NFL  (sports games, who cares really?)
  • SSX (sports games, who cares really?)
  • Tony Hawk (sports games, who cares really?)
  • Need for Speed
  • Far Cry
  • Bully
  • Splinter Cell
  • Prince of Persia
  • Driver
  • Guitar Hero
  • Rock Band
  • The Godfather
  • Scarface
  • Zack and Wiki
  • Geometry Wars (indies?)
  • The Simpsons Game
  • Trauma Center
  • Elebits
  • Spyro the Dragon
  • No More Heroes
  • Red Steel
  • Harvest Moon (Story of Seasons) (3ds has plenty of)
And that’s just one year of releases.

Since we’re counting games a console has access to, the Wii had access to the Gamecube library and the most extensive back catalogue virtual console of any console existing. 
The real story is that Wii launched with what turned out to be the biggest killer app in videogame history, and capped off its first year with one of the most critically acclaimed games in history. In its lifetime the 3DS didn’t have any games of this caliber.

 

 

But how many "meaty" proper full length high quality RPGs did the wii have? man it was slim pickings.
3DS owns the Wii+Gamecube when it comes to RPGs to a degree, I think 3DS is a better game library.

I dont "feel" like the wii had that many standout titles tbh.
You got a Wii, the must haves where like:

Xenoblade Chronicles (which 3ds also has)
the Mario Galaxy (I&II) games
Resident Evil 4
DKC-Returns
Skyward Sword

5 big "must have"s imo, but the 3DS has tons of games at that level.

You crossed off sports games for being sports games. That is a monumental mistake. There is a certain type of game that comes out every single year with only slight changes and sells millions every year despite being essentially the exact same game as the year before: sports games.

Someone brought up that Nintendo tends to have lower attach rates. I would say that is because of sports games. Xbox and PS have always have much better sports games support than Nintendo has had (even genesis was the more sporty system than SNES). Your typical late teen or early twenties male video game player plays sports games. And they buy the same sports game every year or two. Look at Fifa, I can't believe how much that sells now, its almost at the Call of Duty level of millions of people buying the same damn thing every year. I didn't pay attention to video games from like 2012 until 2017 (the Switch brought me back in) and when I came back to this site I was flabbergasted by the monster that Fifa games had become.

Sports games inflate sales because huge sports fans will buy the same game every year.

So sure if you're talking about quality of a system's software in a historical context its easy to overlook sports games because who cares outside of that rare sports game that seems stands out or is memorable (for me I think of NBA Jam, NBA Live '95, NFL 2k, Virtual Tennis). I mean who now is gonna be like aww man Fifa 2008 and 2009 really blew me away? Right! But since we're talking about sales, sports games drive lots of repeat software sales every single year and they bring a whole demographic of gamers to a system simply by having the same sports game come out on a yearly basis on a system.

Nintendo's big games are franchises that for the most part come out once a generation. But they have had shoddy sports games support for most of their history now and therefore have missed out on probably like 20 million people in the world who will buy the same 2-3 sports games every couple of years. Your typical American sports gamer is probably gonna buy a couple Fifas, a couple NBAs, a couple NFLs games and maybe pick up one MLB game and one NHL game. And for europeans they'll probably buy the same Fifa game every year or two. And that in a single genre of games! The only game outside of sports that has found a yearly audience of just rinse and repeat for repeat sales is Call of Duty. Some games like Guitar Hero tried that and the market eventually dried up as it got over saturated, sports games will never become over saturated because sports fans care about having the current rosters.

If Switch can get all the major sports games (and good version of them) that could potentially bring in a lot of sports gamers who are like hell yeah I wanna be able to play Madden or Fifa on the go.

Last edited by Slownenberg - on 07 April 2018