By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
SpokenTruth said:
narfwack said:

The media has blown racism way out of proportion for the US, showing a very vocal minority on both sides for ratings. There is no systemic racism and laws prevent it from ever happening. 

Unfortunately, you are speaking from a position that is not impacted by the problem and therefore you don't experience it and so to you, it doesn't exist.

 

SpokenTruth said:
Aeolus451 said:

 

When you're using someone's race or sex as a basis to undermine their arguments or to determine the worth of their arguments or exclude them, that's a bit fucked up and racist/sexist. I'm really starting to believe in the horseshoe theory when I see stuff like this. 

 You used Anita's website as a source on a gaming forum and you expect me to take as a credible source? 😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹

She writes there but not that piece.  Did you even bother to read it?  Any of it?  Any of those? 

And your horseshoe theory insinuation doesn't apply.  Experience in a given context based on race, gender, sexual orientation, religion, age, etc..has more validity than by those who do not experience it because of their race, gender, sexual orientation, religion, age, etc....  You are trying to make it appear negatively discriminating when it's not.  Is a mother or a father more likely to provide information on the experience of pregnancy and child birth?  You are claiming that I am being sexists if I say the mother.  Is a 5 year old or an 65 year old more likely to provide information on the experience of being 60?  According to you, I'm being ageist if I say the sexagenarian.   Is a Muslim or a Baptist more likely to provide information on the experience inside a Mosque?  By your reasoning, I am being discriminatory if I say the Muslim.

Therefore, if I dismiss a white male for denying systemic racism, you can't call that itself as racism.  It's a factor of experiencing the issue at hand.

She writes there is good enough to say anything from there is trash. Sift out the opinion pieces, blogs, anything using anecdotal experiences as proof. I want actual data from objective sources or unbiased facts that's backed up. 

I requoted the intial post I responded to so maybe we'll get back to the root of this. We're not talking about experiencing pregnancy or going to a mosque.

You're using his race as a basis to undermine his argument. He can't know of systemic racism because he's white, right?