The Long Fall Back To Earth - Jars of Clay (in its own league really)
Here are the top 10 (not including TLFBTE)
The Overflow - Taylor Sorensen
Inland - Jars of Clay
Jars of Clay - Jars of Clay
Truly Madly Completely: Best of Savage Garden - Savage Garden
Secret Codes and Battleships - Darren Hayes
Welcome to The Masquerade - Thousand Foot Krutch
Real Emotion - Paper Route
Secret Weapon - MXPX
U218 - U2
Turn Off The Stars - Turn Off The Stars
1doesnotsimply