Amazon U.S. February bestsellers and general Amazon-based discussion

[Jranation]

SWORDF1SH said:

Jranation said:

 

 

Because Kerotans first reply was saying "all amazon charts". He did not mention anything about Gamestop, Media Create and NPD being listed in the OP. 

 

So I asked why are people talking about these other sources besides Amazon here (since MC and NPD have their own specific threads). 

 

Then he said that its fine cause including other sources here have the same purpose as talking about Amazon = To estimate sales. 

 

And then Swordman thought that I was trying to stop people from providing these other sources in here. When In reality I was just answering someone's question who thought this was just ALL ABOUT AMAZON. 

 

Oh dang! Idk why you 2 even quoted me when my answer to Agente is the same as you 2. 

 

And Glad to see Switch tanking everything else in the hardware chart. 

You're twisting yourself inside out. So it's OK to bring in other sources but it's not?!? That's basically what you just said. 

You questioned why people bring in data from NPD and MC because they have their own threads but I don't believe that statement either because you originally said NPD, MC and Gamestop. Gamestop doesn't have it's own thread so that along with "etc" makes it sound your questioning if we should be able to bring in any other data other than amazon. 

Your reply to Kerotan made your reply to agente sarcastic.

I asked that question to my first quote to Kero because I thought he was disagreeing with me. 

 

"It's been stated many times before this thread is for all amazon charts discussion. Why do you think all the regional charts are listed in the OP ? "

 

When he said this I thought he meant that ONLY  All amazon charts are accepted, while other sources are not. Because the other souces are not in the OP (Which Kero mentioned in the OP)