I just watched the Last Jedi and (spoiler)....

[Lucas-Rio]

Goodnightmoon said:

Lucas-Rio said:

Almost all youtube analysis are clashing the movie, you found out the two fringe people who are saying the opposite. Ratings don't lie, failing legs at the BO also don't lie after a great start, it has bad word of mouth.

Lucas isn"t saying anything because he probably a "don't speak too bad about us" clause in its sale contract with Disney.

This movie was Guardian of the Galaxy kind of movie, not Star Wars.

The movie has a 7.7 among 200k votes on IMDB and a 86 out of 54 critics on metacritic, no, those 2 are not the exception at all, I show you those cause they are pretty big in what they do, one in movie criticism and the other directing movies, not just 2 random fans with no clue about cinema.

7.7 isn't that good and IMDB is not raw data and ratings, it is being calculated .

On Metacritic, it's 4.7/10 for the people. On RT, it's 3.2/5 , with only 53% approbation rate. And as the time goes on, the scores are lowering a little.

As we have seen, the opinion of professional who are all friends with each others and supporting of each other are worthless in this case. That's the biggest rift between fans and professionnals.