So, was 3D World better than Odyssey? S-P-O-I-L-E-R-S

[benji232]

leedlelee said:
3D World and Sunshine shouldn't even be in any conversations regarding the best 3D Mario experience (or 2D, or Kart or Party or whatever)...
3D World was by no means bad, but lacked the scope of prior 3D Mario experiences...
Sunshine was just straight up incomplete and poorly executed...
The blue coins were a piss poor substitute for desperately needed content (much more so that Galaxy's parankster comets, as the Shadow Mario races were pretty fun)...
And need we bring up the terrible Yoshi mechanics or the horrifically buggy pachinko level???
People need to stop saying that Sunshine is criminally underrated and be happy that more people aren't calling it steaming hot garbage...

Speak for yourself as I found 3D world more satisfying in the end then Odyssey. Their both very different games (arguably different genres), but as a platforming fan instead of collectathon, I vastly prefer the incredible and tight level design of 3d world then the 50-60% meaningless moons that you find in Odyssey just floating in open-areas or purchased with coins. And when I say 50-60% of the moons being pretty much there just for the sake of it, I'm being generous as I'm sure that if I went back and counted how many moons feel that way, I'm sure that % could be even higher....

But in the end, it's all opinions. You can't say that X game has to be excluded from a discussion when their all highly regarded games.