| Ka-pi96 said: There's no reason a family in a house shouldn't be able to declare their own independence. I'd support that too. And your second example, while it is indeed better, still doesn't work. Yes, they can leave, but like I said if they personally own land or other assets the company uses then they can and will take that with them. I have no doubt plenty of Catalan people do own their houses and land. So why shouldn't they be able to take that with them if they want to leave Spain? And as for not Catalan's that own land and live in Catalonia? Well they deserve the right to vote on whether Catalonia should be independent as well. Any and all residents of Catalonia should be part of that decision. |
Then at least you are consistent with yourself. If you support someone's bid for independence inside the house or land they own then you supporting a region doing the same makes sense within your logic.
But I still disagree cause if we don't have a structure in which a country has the highest authority and last word in deciding and the lower the level (regions, cities, streets, houses) the less the level of decision making then everything turns to chaos, independence happens everywhere and after that inevitable wars, alliances, invasions etc.. in other words: EXACTLY what the world was centuries and millennia ago.
And if I were a non Catalan Spaniard living in Catalonia and I own some land, I don't want to just vote there, I want my land to become independent from Catalonia. And as I said I am sure Catalonia would not agree or allow it. If they did then yes they'd get some logic ground for independence, but they won't let me and my Catalonian owned land become independent of them. So while you are consistent with yourself, Catalonia is not... And before you say: I don't know that for sure, I did not ask the Catalonian government if I may buy land and declare independence from Catalonia. Well while technically true, you and I know very well they would not allow my bid for independence anymore than the Belgian government would allow my house to become independent or your government would allow your house to become independent.
Last edited by CrazyGamer2017 - on 05 November 2017
