First Super Mario Odyssey Review in! (EDGE)

[Shaunodon]

Azuren said:

RolStoppable said:
List of games with a top 10/10 score

Title	Platforms	Issue	Year
Super Mario 64[23]	Nintendo 64	E035	1996
Gran Turismo[24]	PlayStation	E055	1997
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time[25]	Nintendo 64	E066	1998
Halo: Combat Evolved[26]	Xbox	E105	2001
Half-Life 2[27]	Windows	E143	2004
Halo 3[28]	Xbox 360	E181	2007
The Orange Box[29]	PlayStation 3, Windows, Xbox 360	E182	2007
Super Mario Galaxy[30]	Wii	E183	2007
Grand Theft Auto IV[31]	PlayStation 3, Windows, Xbox 360	E189	2008
LittleBigPlanet[32]	PlayStation 3	E195	2008
Bayonetta[33]	PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, Wii U, Windows	E209	2009
Super Mario Galaxy 2[34]	Wii	E215	2010
Rock Band 3[35]	PlayStation 3, Xbox 360	E222	2010
The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword[36]	Wii	E234	2011
The Last of Us[37]	PlayStation 3	E255	2013
Grand Theft Auto V[38]	PlayStation 3, Xbox 360	E259	2013
Bayonetta 2[39]	Wii U	E272	2014
Bloodborne	PlayStation 4	E279	2015
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild	Nintendo Switch, Wii U	E304	2017

LittleBigPlanet and Skyward Sword? What were they smoking?

 

Although they do have Bloodborne on there. Can't disagree with that. In fact the only titles I disagree with being given 10/10 are LBP, Skyward Sword, and the Devil May Cry clones Bayonetta games. That said, I am curious as to how Halo 1 and 3 made the cut, but not the best (Halo 2).

I'm not sure how much of LBP you actually tried but that game is a legit classic.

Halo 1 pioneered the formula, Halo 2 evolved it, and Halo 3 perfected it. Sounds about right that Halo 2 just misses out.

If anything there were some notable omissions (Red Dead Redemption, Xenoblade, Deus Ex, Metroid Prime, Bioshock all come to mind).