First Super Mario Odyssey Review in! (EDGE)

[Nuvendil]

NintendoPie said:

Green098 said:

I don't think there was anything wrong with him doing reviews, I just don't know why on earth they were being taken as seriously or with the same value as EDGE for example being included on metacritic.

Completely agree here. I wouldn't mind if Jim continued on with his reviews in his little corner of the internet, but he is not a critic and shouldn't be treated as such.

Also, Prime 4 isn't getting a 10. I doubt it'll even get above maybe a 92 consensus.

Original Prime was a 97, Prime 2 a 92, and Prime a 90, Prime Trilogy a 91.  It has a very good chance, if it improves on the very good foundations made for it, that it will land between 92 and 97.  A wide range, but a very plausible one.  We will be able to give a better guess when we actually see it.  Right now we can only go on pedigree and gut, not the strongest bases for a guess.