The director was bad (which is obvious by looking at his filmography, Godzilla and Monsters lol), there was no talent behind the camera, the scenes were boring and uninspired, it has little value when it comes to cinematography, the humor was dumb, the story was fine but the execution was not.
That's not true at all. And who cares about his past films, it's not relevant - Jon Demme made Silence of the Lambs after making Married to the Mob and Something Wild. Rogue One is a great direction, exciting and incredibly inspired scenes. It has the best part of any Star Wars film, and it's not even close:
Lol What? Not in a million years
And critics agree with me on this, that guy is not a good director and its obvious for anyone that has worked in cinema, he wasted the potential of the film.