By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Jumpin said:
Goodnightmoon said:

But Rogue One is one of the worst Star Wars movie lol Only better than episode I and II. The story is fine but the direction its so damn poor its a shame. Star Wars V is better than all Star trek films combined btw.

That's kind of a vague criticism. What aspect about the direction was poor? Why don't you like Rogue One?

Was the plot not contrived or cliched enough?
Was the acting not bad enough?
Was the dialogue not cringey enough?
Were the characters not inconsistent or goofy enough?
Was the film too violent?
Were there not enough blatant merchandize plugs?

The director was bad (which is even more obvious by looking at his filmography, Godzilla and Monsters lol), there was no talent behind the camera, the scenes were boring and uninspired, it has little value when it comes to cinematography, the humor was dumb and unefective, there is no memorable scenes apart from the end, the story was fine but the execution was mediocre for the most part, only the final act raised the level.