Well, unsurprisingly I don't really agree with the list. Edge has always rated Final Fantasy XII as the best in the series, which I've never understood, and I like the game a lot. The fact that no other game from the series is in there already makes this list poor in my opinion.
Arkham Knight being rated as the best game in that series is also weird, and by their own criteria of games having to hold up today rather than ranking based on historical significance should mean that Super Mario 64 wouldn't be anywhere close to that high. As much as I really like that game, it does not hold up nearly as well as people think. The Last Guardian above Shadow of the Colossus is stupid as far as I'm concerned. The more I look at the list the less I like it.








