Poll #3!!!!! Best game ever made? Update/Winner

[StarDoor]

Robert_Downey_Jr. said:

StarDoor said:

What the hell are you talking about? On Metacritic, Super Mario Galaxy is the sixth highest rated game of all time. According to GameRankings, which doesn't give preferential weight to some reviewers, it's the literal highest rated game of all time.

wow.  It's sad if this is true.  That's like Mad Max Fury Road winning 12 oscars or something.  Like it's cool but...damn talk about overrated.

Well, if you base your definition of overrated as "something that I did not enjoy as much as critics or the general population did," then sure.

If you're trying to say that Super Mario Galaxy is overrated in some objective sense, then you're clearly wrong.