Honestly, as someone who's been fan for some 30 years, I'm not too fixed on absolute canon facts (well except that Klingons look abysmal)...but Trek should be about exploration, science, different societies, cultures and morality, and from what I've seen from trailers, STD so far looks like Jar Jar's crap instead.
It's similar in many ways how they ruined Stargate, wanting "serious" post-BSG show, hoping for "wider audience", instead of sticking to campy show SG-1 and Atlantis always were.







