Xbox 360 or PS3?

[Euphoria14]

starcraft said:

Euphoria14 said:

 

There is your problem. What you think AAA means is wrong. Look at his PS2 list. According to you that entire list is not AAA.

AAA is only determined by those who purchase the game. Not some site like Metacritic or Gamerankings that majority of the gaming population couldn't care less about.

You really think having more 90+ rated games means a system is better? Even when those ratings are done by people who's taste differ from the OP?

You know how many games were rated 90+ and recieved the all mighty AAA status and wind up sucking hard? We all know reviews can't be trusted these days so the AAA argument is moot.

He also enjoys RPG's from what I have seen and the PS2 library blows away any RPG released on the 360 thus far, and I know as a life long RPG fan and owner of just about each mediocre to high quality 360 offering at the moment.

Leaving aside the argument over Metacritic, where have I said he shouldn't buy a PS2?

I've said (a million times now) that he should buy a 360 now and purchase a Ps2 after the price drop?

Oh, and you should answer Squilliam's response to your post. 

 

 I know you said he should buy a PS2, but if he wants a PS3 at some point as well, why pay $400 for a PS3 and $130 for a PS2 when he can get both for $500 and have the PS2 problem taken care of as well as his wanting for a BluRay player?

Other than him wanting Banjo, the 360 makes no sense. No 360 RPG at the moment is worth a system purchase.

Honestly if he wants a 360, he should wait for a price drop. I see one possibly this holiday since it hasn't dropped in forever.