By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
StarDoor said:

I put together a table of the 24 (out of MK8D's 40) reviewers who scored both games.

Publications MK8 MK8D Increase
3DJuegos 90 95 +5
Cheat Code Central 84 100 +16
COGconnected 89 89 ~0
Destructoid 90 95 +5
Digital Spy 80 100 +20
Digitally Downloaded 70 90 +20
Game Informer 93 93 ~0
Game Revolution 100 80 -20
Gameblog.fr 90 100 +10
GameSpot 80 90 +10
GamesRadar+ 80 100 +20
God is a Geek 90 100 +10
Guardian 100 100 ~0
IGN 90 93 +3
JeuxActu 90 90 ~0
Meristation 93 95 +2
Metro GameCentral 90 100 +10
Nintendo Life 90 100 +10
NintendoWorldReport 75 85 +10
Post Arcade 80 85 +5
Shacknews 80 90 +10
USgamer 90 100 +10
Vandal 93 94 +1
TOTAL 87.3 94.1 +6.8

Very cool!

Everyone seems to be approaching it in their own way. Some keep the previous version in mind and grade based on how many improvements there's been, others grade it as if the first never existed, some acknowledge both, and some are giving some credit to the new version as it's on a portable console.

They're all over the place.