That list is pretty insulting, to be honest. If those are the most over-rated games of all time, then the gaming industry is a shiny pot of excellence in an otherwise crap brown money driven world.
However, the reality is those aren't even close to being the most over-rated games of all time. Here is the real list, from yours truly from the PS1-PS3 eras:
10. The Elder Scroll Series: Morrowind and Oblivion. Excellent WRPGs, but these games score so well based on their vastness, they are great, but they are pretty much at least 5 to 10 percent over-rated on average.
9. Halo 3: It's a great game, but it just didn't evolve the series and certainly doesn't deserve to be called one of the best games of all time.
8. Disgaea 2: Cursed Memories, with an 85/100, nosir, that game isn't as good as Disgaea 1 by a longshot. It's over-rated by a good little bit, while Disgaea 1 is under-rated.
7. Final Fantasy X-2: It's not bad really, just about 8 percent over-rated
6. Nascar 2005: Chase for the cup 88/100 gamerankings
5. Tony Hawk Pro Skater series as a whole: You can hardly find one under 90/100. At least 3 of them are significantly over-rated.
4. Nintendogs - Obviously
3. Chrono Cross(It's good, but over-rated when you look at other JRPGs) 92/100 gamerankings(10/10 gamespot)
2. NCAA Football 2004: 93/100 gamerankings(This is a madden knockoff with crowd noise, and it didn't deserve AAA then, it doesn't deserve it now. Trust me, I played the hell out of it.)
1. Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty: 95/100 gamerankings, this game nearly ruined the MGS series, and it's one of the worst games and biggest dissapointments that I have personally, ever played.
I don't need your console war.
It feeds the rich while it buries the poor.
You're power hungry, spinnin' stories, and bein' graphics whores.
I don't need your console war.
NO NO, NO NO NO.
