I'd say get Super Mario Galaxy first
My impression from the first 5 hours developed like the following:
Meh..
Mmmkay
Disorienting WTF
Oh..
Nice
This isn't so bad
Cool
Music is kinda nice
This thing is beautiful
Man
So much creativity
Wow
Fuck
WOW
No, it's not going to stop 'Til you wise up
No, it's not going to stop So just ... give up
- Aimee Mann