Torillian on 05 June 2008
OK, let's use what you've said then. Noone who specifically dislikes the series should review it, but even given the assumption that both of these reviewers specifically dislike MGS as a series, they didn't give it poor reviews. An 8 is a fine review, and if you look at it as being from a non-fan then it's even better. If they were giving MGS4 a score of 3 and spewing hate in their then I would agree that their reviews are ridiculous. But giving the game an 8 is perfectly fine and not worthy of notice.
...
