Ars Techina re-reviews the PS3...

[starcraft]

MikeB said:

starcraft said:

Diomedes1976 said:
Some PS3 exclusives (that have at least earned some 9s)

Folklore
Eye of Judgement
Resistence Fall of Man
Motorstorm
Everybodys Golf Out of Bounds(World Tour in Europe)
Valkyrie of the Battelfield
Disgaea 3
Yakuza 3
Uncharted
Ratchet and Clank
Singstar Online
Heavenly Sword
Metal Gear Solid 4:Guns of the Patriots
Gran Turismo 5:Prologue


I think the 360 doesnt have much more than this as exclusives of high caliber ,and less now that Bioshock is coming to the PS3.

Only a handful of those titles are over 80 on Metacritic.

Only MGS4 is over 90.

 

I think whatever the US media in general says isn't any true measure of titles being good, interesting and fun or not. They sure affect sales, but it comes far more down to personal taste and the reviewer's opinion may not fully reflect on general consumer taste. For example the hugely popular Wii Sports only ranked 76% on metacritic (my gf and sister love it!). Wii Play a game which sold more than Gears of War and Halo 3 combined, only scored 58%.

To me it seems quite obvious some US (especially Gamespot) and UK based media have been infiltrated by some 360 fans judging from some of their reasoning and inconsistent criticism. So the scores are not all saying, IMO games like R&C: TOD and Uncharted are top and Super Stardust HD kicks the arse of any Live game out there.

Do you perchance have a better means of injecting anything resembling independant 'fact' into these kinds of discussions?

Also, I dont understand why you think highlighting the gaming media's bias against the Wii and casual titles (Wiisports & Wiiplay) helps prove an argument that PS3 games are underrated?