One Month Later, Where Do You Rank Breath of the Wild?

[JakDaSnack]

malistix1985 said:

JakDaSnack said:

Well if you ever have a chance to play Zelda, you should it's a lot of fun;). Ok, I am highly suspicious that you actually played the game.  

Reasons:  Your best games are all on the PS4.  It takes roughly 40 hours to finish horizon and 60ish hours minimum to adequately get through zelda and experience most of what it has to offer.  You also mentioned the witcher and neir, witcher is a long game as well, not sure about nier.  Point being that I find it highly unlikely you've finished all those games.   Then u put uncharted 4 on that list, uncharted 4 is by far the weakest entry in the uncharted series outside of the first one.  And finally you said "don't get mad Nintendo fans".  If you weren't biased, then chances are you shouldn't care.

Anyways, that's my case  for why you either havent played it, or haven't  played enough to judge it.  Personally I could care less either way, I just felt like trying to be a lawyer today lol.

I am quite the nintendo veteran, on Wii-U I would rank Zelda behind Xenoblade, which was a charm, altough being able to walk trough cars was weird...

Anyway, Your reasons are lacking not mine, I did not mention Horizon or mention only PS4 games, read again. Personally I do think Uncharted was better and Nier was better recently, but I ment Forza Horizon 3, the racing game on xbox not Horizon, I would personally rank Zelda above that since I did not play Horizon Zero Dawn lol.

The best Zelda games where made on N64 for me but I don't think this zelda topped the witcher for me, personally I liked the more mature setting and story-wise zelda could never hold a candle to most of the games I mentioned, but gameplay wise it is very good and the graphics and world gave me the scense of some of the older games, true "adventur" feeling and I loved that but in the end I think something Nier and Forza Horizon (RACING GAME) did better was just... fun. Zelda started to feel a little like a chore after a certain amount of time and altough I know its possible to finish the game quicker then I did I did want to climb everything and explore everythig but ended up not liking it as much as when I just started.

Now for a game like the witcher every expension, side quest and moment just made me want more. So yeah, theres that.

First off I said "on the PS4" not "only PS4 games".  But you said forza horizon, which obviously tripped me up, because I didn't know if u meant forza horizon 3 or forza and horizon but forgot a comma lol.  Anyways, the issue with the witcher and every other open world games is the invisible walls, after Zelda I just can't go back to that.  The freedom in Zelda is second to none, and while the witcher 3 might have a great story, the story is still told linearly.  And while that works great pre-Zelda, I love that in Zelda I can get as much or as little story as I want. Anyways, Zelda isn't for everyone, it sounds like you prefer a linear game vs open world while i prefer freedom.  OOT and majoras mask were great for their time, but I don't feel they are as good as botw.