For the longest time I never had a game that proved to me that it's worthy of my 10/10. So for awhile I defaulted my 10/10 to Shenmue 1 & 2. Even though I knew it has flaws...Then it happened.
Bioshock Infinite in my opinion is the only game I can confidently say it's a 10/10. Voice acting, presentation, music, and yes even the story was near perfection, and I'm aware that some people either don't get it, or just hate it, but I enjoyed the heck out of that game.