Is Breath of the Wild really that good?

[Wyrdness]

Nem said:

Wyrdness said:

I've played many open world games Witcher included and BOTW is just far better as its approach does things other openworld games don't while doing the majority of things these games do all in one package.

That kind of thing is preference. Please don't feed the other guy that just wants to be annoying.

If we couldnt tell wether a game is good or not in good part by just watching footage, we should all be buying the Slaughtering grounds cause who knows... it might be good?! It's a dumb logic.

The's a difference between  telling whether a game is good or not and figuring out how good a game is, the latter is something that requires actual hands on play with especially with a game with as many things to do in it as BOTW. Believe me what you've seen in any video is not even close to half the things in the game so he's right in that sense even more so as the game is one that rewards players for literally playing in any way they want like someone has just mention, so watching a video of someone else playing how they want will never give you the full picture.