The Last of Us for me, it's just such an incredible production through and through. RE4 was where things started to get action-oriented, which isn't the style that I liked in RE games (RE2 is my favorite in the franchise) and voice-acting and story is okay at best. Gameplay is great though.
TLoU simply tics all the boxes for me, it's not just well produced, it has real substance, a fantastic cast with amazing performances, a great setting and simple but fun gameplay. Practically my only complaint about it is the extremely linear nature of it and the heavy use of scripted events in the levels that reduce the replay value a great deal.







