By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
jason1637 on 27 December 2016
Edit Thread
Intrinsic said:
jason1637 said:

According to you the first post about Sony was impulsive. You're post about Amazon showing a clear winner is also impulsive especially when you push it as a fact. Its not a fact because we don't know the gap between #2 and #20. It could be huge and PS4 is winning but it could also be minimal and with the XB1 Minecraft bundle right after the BF1 could put the XB1 ahead. It's not a fact unless you can provide us evidence of the gap. Seeing as you cant its not a fact and that why its impulsive. You're other statement saying "If the positions between #2 and #20 are substantial, then Amazon has determined the outcome of the month" is better.

The bolded part is you saying CGI is saying PS4 is a winner and stating it as fact.

Funny thing is, as far as this threa is concerned.... this Amazon thread. That statement is actually a fact. PS4 is the winner as far as Amazon is concerned. Never befre has the substance between positions on an amazon thread been in question because..... you know; its just impossible to know that kinda information. Which makes what you are doing (especially if you are basing it all on that little detail) unnecesarily argumentative.

So as far as Amazon is conerned, PS4 is the clear winner for the month of december.

NPD could very well say something different. But this isn't an NPD thread. 

Lol no it isnt. All i said there was that he was impulsing saying Amazon had a clear and decisive winner and i later went on to explain that the PS4 or XB1 could be winning meaning its not decisive.

Well like i said there was a "rumored" 100k gap with pro preorders  and the PS4 pro raning more in Amazon last month. But this month on Amazon there is no Pro preorders and the pro is a lot lower while the Xbox one Minecraft is a lot higher on Amazon. So you can also say the Xbox one could be winning based on this and that the gap could be lower so saying PS4 is winning isnt really a fact when we use Amazon.

No its not because we dont know the gap.

This is a thread thats sorta linked to an NPD thread. Also this is US Amazon thread to give us a look at what console is winning NPD.