Bioshock and Uncharted 2 are masterpiece, they are not.
GTA VCS isn't as good as the 3D home console GTA games, its better in many ways.
GTA IV is terrible, its a good game and remarkable in many ways to this day.
GTA V has a great storyline, it does not.
DMC Devil May Cry is bad, its a very good game.
God of War Ascension is bad, its a very good game.
Games need to have 50 hours of gameplay to be worth $60, they do not.
Uncharted is amazing, its not.
Halo 4 is bad, its a very good game.
Naughty Dog is one of the best devs, they are not.