Which is the most unfairly hated?

[Qwark]

Veknoid_Outcast said:

Jpcc86 said:
Uncharted 3. Cause its a high quality game that deserved every good critic it got. Some people like to hate it because it's not as good as U2, which is setting the standard way too high, or simply because that kind of game does not appeal to their personal taste - which has nothing to do with how good or bad the game itself is.

Everything else in the list has bigger falws to some degree - or it's simply garbage - and the hate is understandable. And Im not sure Star Wars TFA is as hated as this forum wants to believe. Sure theres some stuff to criticize, a lot to nitpick, but its universally loved.

I don't want to pick on you, but I do want to challenge the idea that there's some empirical or objective way to determine goodness or badness when it comes to a medium as subjective as video games. Personal taste has everything to do with how good or bad a game is.

Well objectively we have reviews for games which in huge parts determines whether a game is good or bad. If you don't count those I am sure this game also got quite a few awards. In general people like Uncharted 3 it even has a 8.3 user score on metacritic and 92 critical. So the game is objectively good, but personal taste decides whether a person thinks it's a good game, but a game that is good in general doesn't have to be liked by everyone.