(Updated now with poll) E3: Zelda Breath of the Wild Vs Horizon Zero Dawn = which one has the "wow factor"?

[tolu619]

Why are these being compared? They're not that similar! I'm excited for both. The Zelda series is my favorite game series of all time, so personally, I'm more interested in Zelda. That said,
1. Horizon has more "new" stuff. Everything new in Breath of the Wild isn't new in gaming, it's just new in Zelda. Horizon has a female lead (not new, but still very rare in games) and so far, every living thing we've seen that isn't human or plant is a robot. Never seen that in game. Hence, Horizon is more unique.
2. Horizon has better realistic graphics, but Zelda has one of the best toon graphics I've ever seen, right next to Appleseed Ex Machina, 009 Re: Cyborg and CrackDown3. The explosions are more gorgeous than realistic explosions (maybe because I've realistic too many times) in the eye of this beholder. Art style is probably the only area where Zelda is more unique.
3. Anyone that has played Zelda knows how puzzle heavy it will be. They've told us there are over a 100 shrines (read: micro and mini dungeons), and if there's about 9 dungeons like there usually is, that's a lot of puzzling. Horizon's combat is bound to be deeper and more fleshed out than Zelda's. It's made by Guerrila games.
4. Horizon will have a better story, better cutscenes and probably will be fully voice acted. Zelda will probably have voice acted cut scenes, since we heard an audible voice wake Link up at the start of the game. VERY DIFFERENT GAMES!
I'm still not sure why we're comparing them. Is it because they're both open world and feature a protagonist that can wield a bow? I want to play both for very different reasons, and I'll genuinely be extremely surprised if Horizon is a better game than Zelda (not by my fanboy opinions, but by the opinion of the majority of gamers and critics). That won't stop me from playing Horizon. Why exactly are we comparing them again?