As someone more familiar with Zelda (and the creators), I go with Zelda on 3 and 4. Tie on 2, Horizon on 1 (really, it's not much of a contest). I see the potential on Horizon, I just don't know I can trust the game to live up to what it's showing off. At least I have seen a lot of what is in Zelda and feel like I can have more confidence in the game delivering.
Also, I don't think Horizon is as "original" as people say. When I first saw the trailer, I thought that the story's setting was a bit generic, though I was thinking that it was okay because it's a game and probably a first for gaming (at least on the "AAA" scale). I am interested in seeing how the game will turn out. Hope it does end up as good as it seems to promise, but we've seen a lot of promising games fall flat lately.
