(Updated now with poll) E3: Zelda Breath of the Wild Vs Horizon Zero Dawn = which one has the "wow factor"?

[TheBlackNaruto]

Goodnightmoon said:

bananaking21 said:

what? i cant see anything beyond graphics? give me a break.

so far what i seen in Horizon as A LOT more than just graphcis. i've seen very intense, strategic and high speed action gameplay versus very creative and interesting enemies, aling side stealth gameplay elements. a plot with a very deep back story, interesting setting, unique world, variety of weapons/mods for the bow/arrow. a lush and interesting world that actually feels alive, dialogue choices, a very interesting story, a deep and interesting main character. with the promise of a dymanic weather and and day night cycle. 

ohh, and yes, graphics and an art style that are bounds and leaps better than what Zelda has to offer. 

what i seen with zelda is a barron empty world, uninteresting enemy desgin and mundane combat so far. 

after playing the best open world games the industry has to offer, zelda just doesnt look nearly as impressive. 

I have also played all those open world games you mentioned, half of them get boring in a week, bue that's another story, the thing is I have played them and I still find this amazing, people trying to find things to dislike it was completely expected and If you haven't played a soingle Zelda game in your life then you know nothing about how extremelly polish, charming and fun to play they use to feel once you are actually playing it, you think you can know how good is a game just by the looks of it, but that is only a part of the extremelly superficial culture of gaming of today, where everything has to look like a cinematic generic blockbuster for teenagers to be cool.

What's the issue with people not seeing much in the game yet? Why is it expected? I think the game looks great from the trailer and the treehouse gameplay video. But it still feels like it is missing something to me...it looks like well a good Zelda game like an upgraded WW which is not a bad thing by any means seeing as I thought WW was the best Zelda out of all of them personally. I enjoyed it WAY more than any other Zelda game. So it should be a great game when it releases.

But it did not give the WOW factor which is what the thread title asked...in that Horizon gives more of a WOW factor than Zelda does which is fine. Doesn't mean it will be a better game by any means but it leaves something more to think about. All while Zelda gives you an improved Zelda game feel which is awesome because I feel like if it isn't broke then don't fix it.