By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
JWeinCom on 16 May 2016
Edit Thread
LurkerJ said:
Runa216 said:
Like why not give Wonder Woman the Spear? Why did Lois Lane throw said spear into the water? and no, 'because she's stupid' is not an acceptable reason. How did anyone other than Superman know that Doomsday was Kryptonian? Only he and Lex were there for its creation and only they knew of its origin. Why would batman go "I thought she was with you", When he had actually SENT her the email with the information showing that he knew who she was. He asked for her and was still like "I thought she was with you". Why in the world would Superman say "Save Martha"? NOBODY CALLS THEIR MOTHER'S NAME! that's just so stupid.

Anyway, it's clear throughout this movie that Superman and Batman both are stupid, which spits in the face of the concept of Batman being super smart. It's just dumb that they didn't try to talk it out like Stark and Cap did in the airport scene. Also, it's clear in the Avengers that they're not trying to kill one another. "The plan was to go easy on them" or "You're pulling your punches." Character depth through actions and motivations.

Superman told both WW and Batman: "he is from my world". What else could that mean besides doomsday being from krypton?

 

Why do you want Superman to give the spear to wonder woman? He wasn't gonna ask her to do the job because she seemed stronger than Superman in that fight, it would be un"superman"ish to ask someone to do such a dangerous mission on his behalf.

 

"I thought she was with you". Wonder Woman just blocked a beam coming from Doomsday, similar to the one Superman shoots. Afterwards, she performed a superhero special move lol. It's very logical of Batman to think she is related to Superman. It doesn't necessarily mean that Batman was implying she is on Superman's side. 

 

Maybe Lios was trying to hide the spear? And not just throw it? 

 

You want Superman to say "SAVE MY MOM" when Superman doesn't even belong to earth. How would Batman even realize that his mom is on earth?

 

......Not that I think these are legitimate reasons to hate the movie but seriously, find better things to criticize. Like the fact why in the world didn't Batman and Superman just try to talk it out, that's a good thing to label as stupid, that's an actual problem that made the movie look dumb and you have a point there, but it's diluted with unnecessary nitpicking.. 

I mean, if those kind of things you consider as "plotholes" then please. Do explain how on earth black panther was in a jet following the others without being noticed by all those smarties? Black widow is with guards in a sealed vechile and she comes out unscathed? Arguing for hours over the right way to reduce collateral damage and yet they are blowing up the airport? Scarlet Witch left alone in that fight so that she convenietly interferes when it's the right moment for her to interfere. If the goal was to stop them from reaching the jet or the plane, why didn't just destroy that right away? It's not like they had a problem with leaving wreckage behind..... I am sure I can nitpick on more stuff but it's been a week since I watch the movie.

I can tell you this, both movies are far from being logical and tight.

You are condescending to people who liked BvS telling them there is NOTHING TO LIKE ABOUT IT and when they tell you why you throw a list of mainly non-issues to prove the movie sucks, just lol

Because that isn't their goal.  Their goal was to capture Cap and his team.  If you destroy the jet, they have no reason to be there and can just peace out.  Not to mention that the quinjet costs more than the rest of the airport by a factor of 10 or 20, and it is the Avengers primary mode of transportation.  Destroying it would leave them with difficulties responding any threats that would emerge in the near future.  Runa addressed the other stuff.