Do we need oversight for game reviews?

[Slimebeast]

AEGRO said:

Chazore said:

So because he gave it a 4 it somehow means his opion/tastes are invalid and shit?, because that's generally what I'm getting from folk who lose their minds over the few people who aren't on board the hype train these days.

We're entitled to our opinion and that's generally all there is to it, not we're entitled but when you score it lower you're some mentally challenged retard.

Yes.

There is a BIG difference between the people that complains about a 9, and this specific situation.

As a "professional" game reviewer, there is absolutely NO possible way that a game like Uncharted 4 could score a 4 out of 10.

In what aspects is he basing his score?

How do you rate a game? Presentation, Sound, Graphics, Replayability, etc.

How in the fucking hell he ended up with a 4 out of 10? You tell me. 

There are parameters that every reviewer has to follow, he obviously followed none.

Yes there is a possible way that Uncharted is a 4.

I agree with it. If you are restrictive with your scores, like the movie reviewers are, a typical Hollywood blockbuster gets 2/5 (=4/10). If you think Uncharted 4 is similar to a Hollywood blockbuster, brings nothing new to the table and has important elements that you don't particularly like, 4/10 is a perfectly reasonable score.