By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
FIT_Gamer said:
Angelus said:
Raise your hand if played both, and actually made an objective, informed vote lol

I've only played QB, but I think I could make a case for both in terms of which I'd prefer. QB takes some risks, and it's a very unique experience with its fairly high production quality show integrated into the story. As a game it's very classic Remedy, high on atmosphere, and fantastic storytelling. The game left me with the same impression as Alan Wake (though I do favor that game more), where upon finishing it I thought "wow....I won't see that again this Gen." That's a rare feeling, and you can't overvalue that. Uncharted would never engross me the way that QB was able to.

Now Uncharted 4. It's familiar. If I booted it up right now, I know exactly what I'd get. Amazing set pieces, beautiful environments, a good amount of humor. Basically it's a blockbuster. It's fun. And looking at UC4 and the gameplay improvements that ND made, I'm quite certain that I would be a lot more entertained by the second to second play of UC4 than I was by QB, and that's important, because ultimately that enjoyment is what gaming, at it's core is about.

So, I don't know which is better. But I do know, it's not Zelda. Seriously, Zelda games are overrated, and lame.
Thought I was being all diplomatic and shit up until then didn't ya? Suck it Nintendo fans

I played both, and the only way I could see someone liking QB over Uncharted 4 is they prefer the sci-fi setting of QB over the more traditional action adventure of Uncharted 4. IMO UC4 trounces it in every other way. 

Fair enough. Uncharted 4's story is that good? I wouldn't rate 1-3's storytelling that highly personally