Uncharted 4: A Thief's End Review Thread - MC: 93 / GR: 92.70%

[Mike_L]

CGI-Quality said:

Mike_L said:

Apparently because she (Lucy O'Brien) is criticizing UC4 for being about a man who kills people for the sake of treasures and currently rates it 8.8.

Whereas she (again Lucy O'Brien) praised RotTR even though that is about a woman who kills people for the sake of treasures and rated it 9.3.

I can certainly see the hypocrisy in that, but when judging an 8.8 vs 9.3, I feel like some of UC4's supporter's have behaved in an unreasonable way. And even if it wasn't that close. So what? It's one reviewer's opinion. 

 

Slade6alpha said:

Mike_L said:

Apparently because she (Lucy O'Brien) is criticizing UC4 for being about a man who kills people for the sake of treasures and currently rates it 8.8.

Whereas she (again Lucy O'Brien) praised RotTR even though that is about a woman who kills people for the sake of treasures and rated it 9.3.

The biggest thing I got from her review in progress is that SPOILERS (Maybe) act III's

Dragged out too long

The anti feminist comments are completely rediculous and honestly do not belong on the site IMO. And FFS, it's a fucking 8.8 (as a review in progress, which might not even be the final score). 

 

I agree with both.