By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony Discussion - Uncharted 4: A Thief's End Review Thread - MC: 93 / GR: 92.70%

Tagged games:


Metacritic / GameRankings


Metacritic GameRankings
93 92.70%


CGMagazine (10): Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End will be regarded in the same light as Ocarina of Time and Grand Theft Auto III as a game that pushed the industry to new heights we’ve never seen before.

Playstation Universe (10): “Uncharted 4 is the ultimate video game adventure, a visual masterpiece, and a heartfelt, triumphant conclusion for a PlayStation icon.

TheSixthAxis (10): “Uncharted 4 is more than masterful, bearing the hallmarks of a true system seller. What struck me most as an ardent fans of the series is how much it breaks away from the original blueprint yet manages to amaze on every level. Where many studios step safely from one sequel and into the next, Naughty Dog has taken a gigantic leap, proving yet again they’re the best in the business.

Push Square (10): “A fitting end for one of PlayStation's most famous franchises, Uncharted 4: A Thief's End sits alongside The Last of Us at the apex of cinematic action experiences. Naughty Dog's ability to tell engaging tales is unmatched, with Nate's final chapter expertly balancing bombast against genuinely relatable themes. It won't redefine the genre quite like Uncharted 2, but the developer's boundless ambition means that this is a bigger, better, and more beautiful adventure than ever before.

GameSpot (10): “In its writing, in its design, in its understanding of what makes games unique, Uncharted 4 is something to aspire to. It's a shining example. And we'll be talking about it for years to come.

God is a Geek (10): “I've loved this series from the beginning, but a new high bar has been set in Uncharted 4. Naughty Dog have created a truly memorable game, and one of the very best of the current generation.

NZGamer (9.8): “An epic masterpiece worth saving your gold doubloons for.

GamesBeat (9.8): “Uncharted 4's journey is gorgeous and thrilling. It's full of surprises and callbacks that fans of the series will love. It manages to pay tribute to what came before while offering a satisfying conclusion to Drake's story. If this series truly is done, Uncharted 4 ensures that it's a tale we'll never forget. (9.7): “There are only small flaws for a title that is otherwise incredible, a turning point for videogames in many respects. It's truly an adventure from start to finish, and something that every gamer should experience. (9.5): “Uncharted 4 is one of the best action game ever created. The story doesn't have the same emotional impact of The Last of Us, but it bravely focuses on the characters and their relationships. On the other hand, the tension, the diversity, the pace and the aesthetic value of Nate's last adventure is something we've never experienced before.

Vandal Online (9.5): “Uncharted 4 is one of those rare games where everything has been made out of passion. The narrative is more important now and it won’t be as genre-defining as Uncharted 2, but it’s the biggest and most complete game in the series. If you’re even just slightly interested in video games, you should try Uncharted 4.

XGN (9.5): “Uncharted 4 is Drake's last adventure and absolutely his best one. The game looks fantastic and plays even better. The numerous new features and multiplayer modes bring even more enjoyment. This is a must buy for every PlayStation 4 gamer.

Destructoid (9.5): “That the interpersonal relationships aren't overshadowed by $400 million in pirate gold, or by hundreds of dead mercenaries, is a testament to the caliber of storytelling.

Power Unlimited (9.4): “Uncharted 4 is a worthy and gorgeous end to the legendary Uncharted franchise. It’s a bittersweet goodbye, but Drake’s adventure couldn’t have ended in any better way.

Hardcore Gamer (9): “Naughty Dog has done it again, creating a cinematic marvel that sets the bar for the action genre. There are a couple of off moments throughout the story and the multiplayer, while a decent component, lacks the variety other games deliver, but the thirteen hour single player campaign will blow you away. It’s filled with an intriguing mystery, heart-wrenching emotional scenes, incredibly over the top set pieces, and of course the humor fans have come to love from our plucky (now older) hero and his trusty sidekicks.

Attack of the Fanboy (9): “One of the few PS4 exclusives that lives up to the "Greatness Awaits" slogan. There's a special element to games from Naughty Dog that deliver the type of single player experiences that can stand on their own, offering the perfect blend of story telling, visuals, and gameplay -- everything else I just consider a bonus.

Eurogamer Italy (9): “Uncharted 4: A Thief's End is simply amazing. Naughty Dog has done an incredible job with the last chapter of this epic franchise, creating a deep, emotional and entertaining experience for both the movies and video games addicted. If you have a PlayStation 4, buy this game and live a gorgeous adventure around the world.

We Got This Covered (9): “With Uncharted 4: A Thief's End, Naughty Dog has delivered another gorgeous, action-packed and memorable epic. Although it's kept from perfection by some pacing issues and a couple of other minor quibbles, it's a jaw-dropping experience that offers a lot of bang for one's buck. As such, it's something that every PlayStation 4 owner, and self-respecting gamer, should play through at least once.

Digitally Downloaded (8): “In terms of giving the fans what they want, I’m certain Naughty Dog has nailed every part of the brief that it was given. Uncharted 4 shows a truly masterful eye for detail and is near perfect in mechanical execution. It’s also presented with cinematic brilliance. My issues with the game are less about it in isolation than it as representative to the broader AAA-blockbuster space. I am increasingly uncomfortable with the superficiality of these games, and the way that they work so hard to hide just how passive you are as a participant.

VideoGamer (8): “It's a confident, assured, and rather more intelligent game than it first appears, and a strong end to the series.



BraLoD 96 ZODIARKrebirth 94 KLXVER 92 hamo0odi90 96 Octane 91
TheEighthByte 94 FloatingWaffles 92 spurgeonryan 95 Panama 88 Risthel 94
StokedUp 92 Nautilus 95 finalrpgfantasy 90 Chevinator123 95 Wright 89
RolStoppable 94 JustBeingReal 94 TJZ_Link 93 WoodenPints 87 TheBlackNaruto 95
VGPolyghot 90 leyendax69 92 Hiku 93 Ruler 85 binary solo 92
bananaking21 88 Turkish 95 FIT_Gamer 96 DonFerrari 95 OttoniBastos 90
John19 93 claudius_l 83 X1Gates 97 sales2099 92 twintail 97
Nemesis1993 95 CWegzz 92 Dirtybynature 94 Squall_Leonhart 95 Jicale 98
sub-zero-TM 94 Erazor_DJ 96 cesarmgc 96 Anfebious 93 Guitarguy 92
Sh1nn 96 Dr.Vita 95 Normchacho 94 DEAD_ORIGINAL 99 Hynad 95
paulrage2 95 Mike_L 94 Danman27 94 avais1993 96 BlowoverKing 91
poklane 94 Teeqoz 92 Miguel_Zorro 96 Tmfwang 96 WebMasterFlex 93
JRPGfan 97 ArchangelMadzz 94 the_dark_lewd 95 Acevil 94 flint 94
Angelv577 93 Manlytears 93 Kerotan 93 Ucouldntbemorewrong 92 ABTR 69
Qwark 94 NobleTeam360 92 DivinePaladin 94 fleischr 87 John2290 97
Robert_Downey_Jr. 92 TheMagicMax 95 CosmicSex 93 melbye 96 TheLastDon 95
spemanig 94 Mr_No 97 LipeJJ 91 RJ_Sizzle 89 Uabit 92
QUAKECore89 98 HylianYoshi 94 xl-klaudkil 93 REDZONE 93 gintama 97
Mummelmann 95 Slade6alpha 88 Shikamo 94 LudicrousSpeed 88 mah575992 93
pokoko 90 Aerys 94 HEMSTAR 95 qbi 94 Trunkin 88
aceitman 97 Roronaa_chan 91 CGcarmineCG 97 Nate4Drake 94 V-r0cK 97
Low78wagon 94 Sunstrider 93 Boutros 95 Neoarc 94 Carl2291 92
BluePokegon 93 ClassicGamingWizzz 94 Paatar 92 celador 86 Swordmasterman 93
TheGoldenBoy 91 Shadow8 93 VXIII 91 Ballas 97 Eikichi134 95
GribbleGrunger 95 axumblade 89 Ultrashroomz 93 estebxx 97 Natsu 89
ktay95 93 zehh25 88 Sprash 96 Farsala 90 slip123 91
the-pi-guy 94 BillyBong 94 rccsetzer 94 Zanten 92 Lawlight 84
slowpoker 100 Colocho 91 think-man 90 betacon 98 TallSilhouette 95
Kowan 96 Namiirei 96 tendoronie67 96        

*Only one prediction per user, only whole numbers between 0-100, exact numbers, no ranges.
**Predicitons will only be accepted until before May 5th (review embargo lift).
***Predictions will compare to the Metacritic score only.


Around the Network

My prediction is 96


Hardware owned:

PC, PS4, 3DS, Wii, Xbox 360, PS3

Most anticipated games (near to mid future):

Zelda U/NX
The Last Guardian                            


PSN ID: Stokesy 

Add me if you want but let me know youre from this website

I predict a Metascore of 94, so a moderate critical flop.


You are foolish for reading this. You could have seriously spoiled the game for yourself. For Nathan's sake, restrain yourself! 

Legend11 correctly predicted that GTA IV (360+PS3) would outsell SSBB. I was wrong.

A Biased Review Reloaded / Open Your Eyes / Switch Shipments

Around the Network

90, to be "conservative".


I'll say 93

95 because click bait sites (Polygon and Quarter to Three)

Oh shiiiiit can't believe it's almost time ! :D so the embargo lifts in three days ?

i say 94