I felt the character arc intended for Supes should have been dominant type rather than the embodiment of brooding(my world no more...no hope WTF?) for pretty much the whole time. Death of Superman arc was never going to work with a wider audience. It worked for me to an extent and I still give the movie a 7 out of 10.
EDIT: What worked for the movie was the older Batman's aggressiveness. That matched the character. Wonderwoman was awesome just as my sig and that turned out to be the saving grace of the movie. If this movie could have done far better among fans it should have exactly ripped off Miller's style and avoided that Doomsday climactic shit and instead used Wonderwoman offensiveness on Supes to protect Bats. I'd now compare this to MArvel's Iron Man 2.
