WW, TP and SS are all great games, I will mentioned only things I dont like about them:
-WW needed more content, one more bigger island like Windfall Island or Outset Island IMO would be perfect.
-TP overworld is so huge, empty and boring, definitely needed more live, populated world with more content, also without sections game would be better.
-SS has terrible backtracking (you going 3 times back in each area), and of course game is too linear.
I would said WW>SS>TP, but again all 3 are great games.
I currently playing TP HD, looks and fells much better than original that I replayed 3 years ago, saying that owerlworld is still huge, empty and boring, still my biggest complain about game, also without wolf sections game would be better. Also TP HD looks better than it looks on screenshots and videos.







